Skip to main content

2022 | Buch

Public Investment Criteria

Using an Interregional Input-Output Programming Model

insite
SUCHEN

Über dieses Buch

This volume presents the most robust and useful methodology for the derivation of investment criteria for the evaluation and planning of public investment projects – public investment criteria. The methodological approach solves inherent defects of traditional methodology, namely an ad hoc application of the benefit-cost analysis in the static content.
Although this approach originated in the water resources development project of the Harvard group, the authors’ methodology has achieved a discrete and dynamic inter regional input-output programming model by which: (i) establishment of priorities among potential investment targets by taking account of economic benefits that are brought by implementation of a set of selected projects, and diffusing into the whole national economy, and (ii) rational allocation of limited public funds to the selected investment projects are consistently made, based on the opportunity cost criteria in the dynamic content. As these benefits make up a source for the stream of further created capital funds for public as well as private sectors over the planning time horizon, optimal re-investment of thus created capital funds are solved recursively in the endogenous model by approaching the turnpike path of the whole national economy. As an optimal solution, the allocated levels for trunk expressway network as well as for other transport facilities, which are balanced with the allocation for industrial capital formation, are obtained by period and by region. In the background of these processes, the imputed price and opportunity costs as a sort of contemporary “god” are always latent.
Readers with basic mathematical knowledge will learn functional and practical meaning of the opportunity costs (and the imputed price) in the evaluation and planning of investment. Conquering this small obstacle will be a source of strong self-confidence for society, a worthwhile objective. Other applications of the methodology are also included in this book, which is helpful for practitioners frequently using the feasibility study method as well as experts who wish to understand the theoretical arguments related to public investment criteria. As one of the applications, there is a numerical solution of a composite transport system in which the amounts of roads, railways, and ports are derived quantitatively, not qualitatively. These are results of authentic public investment criteria that are built in the inter-regional input-output programing model.

Inhaltsverzeichnis

Frontmatter
Chapter 1. Public Investment Criteria: A Tentative-Specific Survey on the Benefit–Cost Analysis in the Early Years
Abstract
Under the scarce total capital fund that is given in advance by the capital rationing through, for example, policy arguments between the alternative sets of investment targets such as the projects of road construction administered by the ministry of construction, the projects of the railway by the ministry of transportation, the projects of research and developments by the ministry of education, science and technology, and so on, the most concern, for example, the ministry of construction, which is in charge of planning and implementation of the projects of road, is to choose a set of projects of road to which the limited fund may be assigned. The ministry or the department in the ministry has to make a kind of selection between projects and determine a certain set of projects in a consistent manner by considering the accountability because it may usually not include all the projects which the department may implement even if the allocated fund through the capital rationing to the department were huge. The static investment criteria work as a sort of Merkmal (an indicator) in the choice of the optimal set of projects consistently in the sense that the additional total social surplus (the sum of consumer and producer surpluses = social benefits), which can be created in the whole national economy owing to the implementation of the optimal set of projects, is greater or at least is not less than the social surplus that is to be created by implementing other sets of projects created through the selection subject to the limited fund.
Hirotada Kohno, Yoshiro Higano
Chapter 2. Economic Effects of Mei-Shin and To-Mei Expressways Based on the World Bank Formula of 50 Years Ago
Abstract
Having ranged over the literature concerning Chap. 1, our eyes fell upon “The Economic Effects of Mei-Shin Expressway (Sasaki et al. 1964),” and we felt that we met with a fossil as it was written 50 years ago and fairly kept out of sight so long. We found that it is a rudimentary report of project evaluation using quite old data in nature, and the system as a whole is yet well-ordered as the World Bank formula had discussed the indirect economic effects in a dignified manner. It was the document prepared and submitted to the World Bank to finance the Project.
Hirotada Kohno, Yoshiro Higano
Chapter 3. Generalized Benefit–Cost Criteria: Public Investment Criteria When Benefits Are Previously Measured
Abstract
The definition in Chap. 1 can be taken as the criterion with which it can be examined whether the allocation of scarce public funds for public projects will achieve the golden rule of resource allocation, that is, the marginal rates of substitution/transformation shall be equated with the price ratios in the dynamic as well as spatial context. The topic of this chapter will play an important role in a practical setting as a positive version of the abstract and general investment criterion that examines the golden rule of resource allocation.
Hirotada Kohno, Yoshiro Higano
Chapter 4. Optimum Allocation of the Capital Funds to the Transportation Infrastructures Using the Interregional Input–Output Programming Model (Part I): Specification with Five Regions, Five Industries, and Three Transport Modes
Abstract
The application of the public investment criteria is made with two stages in the traditional benefit–cost analysis and its sophisticated development by the water resources research group in the United States represented by Eckstein, Steiner, and Marglin (e.g., Marglin 1963). Namely, (1) the calculation of the investment criteria, which is basically the benefit–cost difference, the benefit–cost ratio, or the internal rate of return, with each of investment targets or each of the combinations of investment targets using the discounted present values of costs and benefits that would be incurred and created by the investment target or the combination of investment targets by presuming that it was or they were implemented; and (2) decision on the choice of an optimal set of investment targets in the sense that the objective function in the present value of the net benefits created by the chosen set of investment targets is not less than the other sets of investment targets under the constraint of the limited capital funds that can be allocated for the chosen investment targets.
Hirotada Kohno, Yoshiro Higano
Chapter 5. Optimal Comprehensive Transport System and Development of the Model
Abstract
It is a historic fact that the railway as mono-transport had been so long time the major subject of the national transportation project since the Meiji era. This has been continued till the early 1960s when the Japanese economy had taken off and the motorization was about to start. A paradigm shift had been made and the movement had begun to well place the right shares to right transportation modes including road transport in the market of transportation services based on the general-market-equilibrium-oriented analysis. This is the philosophy and concept of the comprehensive transport system. It is the modern topic in transportation economics in the sense that it must give the right answer with the shares as well as reply to the practical concerns by all related stakeholders in the private sectors and the government ministries or departments under the vertically segmented administrative system.
Hirotada Kohno, Yoshiro Higano
Chapter 6. Optimal Allocation of the Public Funds to the Transportation Infrastructures Using the Interregional Input–Output Programming Model (Part II): Specification with Ten Regions, Ten Industries, and Nine Transport Modes
Abstract
This chapter analyzes the main topic in Chap. 4 with the expanded model specification in terms of the number of: (1) regions; (2) sectors; (3) transportation infrastructures and modes, which transport cargo as well as passengers; and (d) the targets of public investments, which are extended to include social overhead capitals, based on Kohno and Mitomo (1982).
Hirotada Kohno, Yoshiro Higano
Chapter 7. Optimal Planning of Asian Expressway Network Without Dynamic Interregional Input–Output Programming Model
Abstract
The optimal assignments of the exogenously given amount of capital funds for transportation infrastructures and social overhead capitals are treated in Chap. 6. The themes are serious agendas in that day and analyzed with an empirical application of the interregional input–output programming model. As an extension of the shipment activities initiated by Moses in order to include the transportation sector explicitly, shipment activities among the regions and sectors are specified based on the interregional input–output table of competitive-import type. Namely, interregional trades are endogenously determined responding to the relative advantage of regional economies that are mainly dependent on the accessibility to the markets. Usually, the trade patterns which are endogenously and therefore optimally determined should be critically different from the presupposed trade pattern inherent to, for example, Isard-type model. The optimality of the assignment of capital funds for potential investment targets is obtained thanks to the opportunity cost criteria that is intrinsically built into the algorithm for solving the linear programming model. However, the optimality obtained is a static one (Hirschman 1968; Kohno 1991a, b, c, 1992, 1994; Kohno et al. 1987).
Hirotada Kohno, Yoshiro Higano
8. Correction to: Optimal Planning of Asian Expressway Network with Dynamic Interregional Input–Output Programming Model
Hirotada Kohno, Yoshiro Higano
Backmatter
Metadaten
Titel
Public Investment Criteria
verfasst von
Hirotada Kohno
Yoshiro Higano
Copyright-Jahr
2022
Verlag
Springer Japan
Electronic ISBN
978-4-431-55221-5
Print ISBN
978-4-431-55220-8
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-4-431-55221-5